woman wagging finger

Court tells SEC, this is not a security

January 25, 2019

The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a district court’s order granting the SEC summary judgment based upon a finding that certain oil and gas interests were securities. The 5th Circuit provides a detailed analysis of whether the partnership interests satisfy the Howey test. This is well covered in Thomas Gorman’s blog SEC Actions @secactions and should be of interest to folks in the cryptocurrency and blockchain space.

Read more
heart made of hearts

The gift of material nonpublic information

July 11, 2018

Material nonpublic information – the perfect gift The gift of material nonpublic information always fits, is never returned, and can be regifted easily. It is the perfect way to say “I love you.” The SEC has filed an action against Robert Carr and Katherine Hanratty for illegal insider trading in the shares of Heartland Payment Systems, Inc. (“Heartland”), a New Jersey-based company, ahead of its December 15, 2016 announcement that it was to be acquired. 

Read more
Uncle Sam

Securities Law in the Trump Administration – Has Anything Changed?

January 26, 2018

Please join the Chicago Bar Association Securities Law Committee on February 27, 2018 from 3-6 p.m. for three great panel discussions of what in securities law has changed and what has not during the first year of the Trump Administration while getting continuing legal education credits.

Read more
mother rhino and baby

Insider traders who must love their mothers

September 27, 2017

Must be embarrassing for Zacks Investment Research to learn that not one, not two, but three of its employees were trading on illegal inside information for years! According to the SEC’s complaint — see link below — the three are Jason Napodano, Bilal Basrai, and Bryce Stirton. Two of the three were managers of Zacks divisions.

Read more

Do as I say, not as I do – the new SEC motto?

September 22, 2017

According to the SEC, “Issuers and other market participants must take their periodic and current disclosure obligations regarding cybersecurity risks seriously, and failure to do so may result in an enforcement action.” So, brokers, mutual funds, public companies are required to make timely disclosures of material cybersecurity risk information or face an SEC enforcement action. OK SEC, show us how it is done.

Read more
Enron logo

Financial reporting controls should be verified or why bother?

September 11, 2017

The president of NYSE Group (Tom Farley) is leading the chorus of industry folks complaining about having to ensure that public companies have adequate controls in place to make their financial statements meaningful.

Read more

Shine a little light on FINRA say industry and investor advocates

September 9, 2017

With members and investors unhappy with FINRA, it would appear to be time for the SEC to step in. Investor advocates have been complaining about FINRA for a long time. FINRA has made some modest changes but largely resisted changing anything.

Read more
empty courtroom

SEC administrative law judges – constitutional or not?

September 7, 2017

The US Supreme Court may step in to resolve an issue that has been simmering for many years — does the SEC have the authority to bring enforcement actions before administrative law judges that it has appointed and who work for the agency. Opponents of SEC ALJs contend they are “inferior officers” whose appointment violates the “Appointments Clause” of the US Constitution. This argument has been rejected by SEC Commissioners, who are appointed by the president and who hear appeals of ALJ decisions. Federal appeals courts, however, are not in agreemen — some courts concluding the ALJs are properly appointed, others not. There is little evidence that SEC ALJs are in the pocket of the Division of Enforcement. Far from rubber stamping actions brought by the Division of Enforcement,  ALJs have ruled against the SEC Division of Enforcement in significant cases. The SEC’s success in administrative proceedings is similar to its success in federal court actions. The SEC doesn’t lose often because it has the ability to conduct investigations before bringing enforcement actions. As a result, by the time a case is filed, the SEC has a great deal of evidence supporting its charges. Requiring the SEC to file all cases in federal court might be a boon to investors. Investors can learn more about a case filed in federal court than an administrative action. SEC administrative proceedings are “public” in name only. Just try to attend an administrative proceeding and you will see how “public” they are. Not only do the ALJs often bar you from the hearing room, but the SEC makes it exceedingly difficult to obtain even some of the exhibits or transcripts of testimony in these so-called public proceedings. How is that public? https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/business/dealbook/in-house-judges.html?em_pos=small&emc=edit_dk_20170906&nl=dealbook&nl_art=7&nlid=62722730&ref=headline&te=1&_r=1

Read more

Everything old is new again – bribery of Haitian officials

September 4, 2017

As an SEC enforcement attorney, I investigated the CEO and senior executives of American Rice for bribing Haitian customs officials. Under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA), it is illegal for US companies to pay bribes to foreign officials. In addition, when companies fail to identify those bribes in their financial statements they violate other federal securities laws requiring proper disclosures — when is the last time you saw a line item for “bribes.” These guys were flying suitcases of cash to Haiti to be secretly handed off to Haitian customs officials. As a result of investigations by the SEC and DOJ, American Rice’s CEO and another senior executive were convicted of criminal FCPA violations. https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr18925.htm An SEC Litigation Release concerning the filing of the SEC enforcement action against Douglas K. Murphy and is available here: https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr17651.htm Bribes paid to Haitian officials are back in the news. A retired U.S. Army colonel was charged with involvement in a foreign bribery and money laundering scheme in connection with a planned $84 million port development project in Haiti. According to a DOJ press release (available below along with an FCPA Blog post), Joseph Baptiste was arrested Tuesday morning on a criminal complaint filed in federal court in Boston. He was charged with one count of conspiracy to violate the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and to launder money. Baptiste is alleged to have solicited bribes from undercover FBI agents in Boston, who posed as potential investors in a port project in Haiti. Baptiste allegedly told the agents in a recorded meeting that he would funnel payments to Haitian officials through a Maryland non-profit he controlled. The complaint alleges that Baptiste took $50,000 from the undercover agents that was wired to the non-profit. Although Baptiste used that money for personal expenses, the DOJ said, “he intended to seek additional money from the undercover agents to use for future bribe payments in connection with the port project.” Things in Haiti have not changed much in the past 15 years. As sad as things are in Haiti, it has not always been like that. Here is a link to a “Crash Course” by John Green – an interesting video on the Haitian Revolution. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/retired-us-army-colonel-charged-conspiring-bribe-senior-officials-republic-haiti http://www.fcpablog.com/blog/2017/8/29/retired-us-army-colonel-charged-with-fcpa-conspiracy.html

Read more
crumpled dollar bill

Almost 10 years ago – the beginnings of the Great Recession

August 24, 2017

Periodically I go back to one of the best financial podcasts ever – The Giant Pool of Money podcast produced by WBEZ’s This American Life. In this program, public radio journalists relate in a clear and interesting way the causes of the housing crisis and subsequent financial collapse of 2008. They address questions like, what did the housing crisis have to do with the turmoil on Wall Street? Why did banks make half-million dollar mortgage loans to people with no job and no income? How did these risky no-doc (liar’s) loans get rolled into collateralized mortgage obligations (CMOs) that were marketed as low risk investments? As we are now approaching the ten year anniversary of the housing crisis/liquidity crisis/Great Recession, it is worth revisiting what happened and why Congress enacted Dodd-Frank. https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/355/the-giant-pool-of-money

Read more